| Número de ID del error |
BUG-000181187 |
| Enviado | November 23, 2025 |
| Última modificación | December 2, 2025 |
| Relacionado con | ArcGIS Pro |
| Versión encontrada | 3.5.3 |
| Sistema operativo | Windows OS |
| Versión de sistema operativo | 11.0 64 bit |
| Estado | Under Consideration
El problema ha sido revisado por el equipo de desarrollo. No se ha priorizado en un plan de lanzamiento y se supervisará para determinar su impacto general. Los factores que se consideran en el proceso de priorización incluyen la cantidad de usuarios afectados o que solicitan la funcionalidad, la repercusión comercial y si existe una solución alternativa, entre otros. Si un error afecta negativamente a su negocio, consulte Soluciones: Escalar un defecto (https://support.esri.com/en/technical-article/000024129).
|
Solución alternativa
Temporary Workaround
The only current workaround is to export the input feature class to a local version without the GlobalID field before running Intersect 3D.
This workaround is not practical in production workflows:
- It requires duplicating data or exporting selected features each time.
- It breaks the connection to the original dataset that relies on persistent GlobalIDs.
- In our workflow, 3D volumetric intersection between cadastral parcels is performed as part of a routine QA process for the 3D cadastre in Israel, where GlobalIDs are required and managed at the database level.
Why This Should Be Considered a Bug
- No documentation indicates that Intersect 3D does not support feature classes containing GlobalID fields.
- From a functional standpoint, there is no apparent reason that the presence of a GlobalID field should interfere with a purely geometric operation.
- Intersect 3D is a commonly used tool worldwide, so it is surprising that this issue has not yet been reported or addressed.
- The current behavior forces unnecessary data duplication and breaks standard data management workflows.
Request
- Confirm and classify this behavior as a BUG,
- Update the Intersect 3D tool to fully support GlobalID fields, or
- Provide clear documentation and meaningful error messages if this limitation is intentional.
This fix is important for supporting robust 3D cadastral workflows in production environments.
Pasos para reproducir