laptop and a wrench

Bug

Performance of Buffer tool with Dissolve ALL option is much slower in ArcMap 10.3.1 and 10.5.1 compared to ArcMap 10.2.2.

Last Published: March 1, 2018 ArcGIS for Desktop
Bug ID Number BUG-000107358
SubmittedAugust 14, 2017
Last ModifiedJune 5, 2024
Applies toArcGIS for Desktop
Version found10.3.1
Operating SystemWindows OS
Operating System Version7.0 64 Bit
StatusKnown Limit

Additional Information

The Buffer tools dissolve ALL option actually runs the dissolve first, not second, and internally something is going on with this that is probably causing the slowdown in 10.3. We made an enhancement to this in 10.5.1 which is why you see the performance recover. However, we also made buffer and dissolve much more accurate up to and including 10.5.1 so some of the slowdown you see there as compared to 10.2 is due to better output. Workaround 1 Run Buffer with dissolve NONE and then run Dissolve on the output of the buffer operation. This takes seconds for a number of buffer distances I tried using the Planar option. Workaround 2 Pro only... run using PairwiseBuffer. By default this runs in parallel. For various buffer distances running buffer with the dissolve ALL option it completed in under 1 minute. Suggestion I noticed that the x,y resolution of this data is much finer than default x,y resolution for the specified Spatial Reference. This is leading to a much larger storage and processing size, which also will lead to other performance issues with any tool that is used to process this data (for buffer it looks like a 30-40% performance hit over using the default x,y resolution). If the data was recorded with a device that actually had this x,y resolution, I am guessing this performance hit is acceptable to you.

Workaround

Run the Buffer tool with Dissolve set to NONE, and run the Dissolve tool separately.

Steps to Reproduce

Bug ID: BUG-000107358

Software:

  • ArcGIS for Desktop

Get notified when the status of a bug changes

Download the Esri Support App

Discover more on this topic

Get help from ArcGIS experts

Contact technical support

Download the Esri Support App

Go to download options