laptop and a wrench

Bug

Map services are not drawn on web maps completely, leading to inaccurate feature count when performing a spatial selection.

Last Published: September 21, 2020 ArcGIS API for JavaScript
Bug ID Number BUG-000131304
SubmittedJune 2, 2020
Last ModifiedJune 5, 2024
Applies toArcGIS API for JavaScript
Version found3.32
Operating SystemWindows OS
Operating System Version10.0 64 Bit
StatusWill Not Be Addressed

Additional Information

When a layer in a map service is used as feature layer in on-demand mode: 1. FL fetches less features per tile request because maxRecordCount is 2000 (whereas the layer has 4938 total features). 2. FL also applies feature generalization based on the current map scale. As a result, features that are too small after generalization have no coordinates at all. 3. When a selection query is executed for the full extent, only features that have coordinates match the query. So, only a subset of features are selected. 4. As you zoom in, number of features fetched and selected change because: number of request tiles changes, maxAllowableOffset changes. When layer in a feature service is used as feature layer in on-demand mode: 1. FL fetches more features per tile request because it uses resultType=tile and that increases the maxRecordCount to 4000 2. The layer is editable. So, feature generalization is disabled - resulting in features having all their coordinates regardless of map scale. 3. When selection query is executed for the full extent, all features available in memory match the query. This is the reason for the difference in feature count when selecting features in a map service layer versus a feature service layer. This can be fixed in couple of ways: 1. Configure the layer in "snapshot" mode so that the layer will fetch all features up front. An example is provided below, featureLayer = new FeatureLayer( "https://essanalytics.esri.com/server/rest/services/SMRoads/FeatureServer/0", { mode: FeatureLayer.MODE_SNAPSHOT } ); 2. Enable WebGL for the web application by setting "esri-featurelayer-webgl" has flag to true and configure the layer as not editable. An example is provided below: featureLayer = new FeatureLayer( "https://essanalytics.esri.com/server/rest/services/SMRoads/FeatureServer/0", { mode: FeatureLayer.MODE_ONDEMAND, outFields: ["*"], editable: false } );

Workaround

  • Use a feature service.
  • If ArcGIS Web AppBuilder is used, use the map server URL instead of the layer URL. 

Steps to Reproduce

Bug ID: BUG-000131304

Software:

  • ArcGIS API for JavaScript

Get notified when the status of a bug changes

Download the Esri Support App

Discover more on this topic

Get help from ArcGIS experts

Contact technical support

Download the Esri Support App

Go to download options