laptop and a wrench

Bug

The OD Cost Matrix layer produces altered travel time when implementing a point barrier not intersecting with the generated Line.

ArcGIS Pro
Bug-ID-Nummer BUG-000173139
EingereichtDecember 18, 2024
Zuletzt geändertDecember 30, 2024
Gilt fürArcGIS Pro
Gefunden in Version3.4
BetriebssystemWindows OS
Betriebssystemversion10.0 64 Bit
StatusKnown Limit

Zusätzliche Informationen

This type of behavior isn't unusual when solving network analysis problems using hierarchy, which employs a heuristic algorithm to search the network graph quickly at the expense of a small amount of optimality in some cases. Most likely what is happening is the added point barrier is expanding the area of the hierarchical graph search and finding a better result with the barrier compared to without the barrier. When barriers are added, a neighborhood around the barrier where the hierarchical search can behave like a non-hierarchical search is computed, and it tries to find a better path around a barrier. It is possible for the barrier to search with this non-hierarchical neighborhood to result in a shorter path than a hierarchical search because it's examining a part of the network that would be ignored in a normal hierarchical search.

Workaround

For solves always consistent and guaranteed to always return the fully optimal solution, turn off hierarchy, though this makes the solves slower.

Schritte zur Reproduzierung

Bug-ID: BUG-000173139

Software:

  • ArcGIS Pro

Benachrichtigung erhalten, wenn sich der Status eines Bugs ändert

Esri Support App herunterladen

Weitere Informationen zu diesem Thema erkunden

Unterstützung durch ArcGIS-Experten anfordern

An den technischen Support wenden

Esri Support App herunterladen

Zu Download-Optionen wechseln